Legal About turn Chris McGeever, advocacy manager at LPC Law, asks what next for debt recovery fees? ollowing its further technical consultation, which ran from 30 July to 27 August 2021, the government has announced that the new Parking Code of Practice will not permit debt recovery agents or parking operators to add extra fees on top of the parking charge itself. Only 18 per cent of the responses to the consultation had called for this prohibition. The consultation proposed a cap on debt-recovery fees at the existing level of 70. However, while the government recognised that debt recovery agents can provide an additional level of deterrent to contraventions, it considered that there was insufficient evidence to determine whether extra fees were required as part of that deterrent. The consultation response at paragraph [27] stated that no substantial evidence had been provided that additional fees did, in fact, provide an effective incentive for motorists to engage in the process earlier, so as to avoid the additional amounts payable. F Additional safeguards The use of debt recovery agents will remain permitted, subject to additional safeguards, such as a ban on misleading and intimidatory language in communications, which includes a list Review period There will be a two-year review of the Code following its implementation, in which the government will consider whether to revise the ban on debt recovery fees. Factors it will take into account include changes to: The level of compliance with parking charges The volume of court claims for unpaid parking charges Any changes in the practices and behaviour of recovery agencies (for instance, adherence to language requirements) as a result of the new certification scheme. The new Parking Code of Practice will not permit debt recovery agents or parking operators to add extra fees on top of the parking charge itself of prohibited words and phrases. There must also be greater deference for vulnerable customers. The 32 per cent of respondents who disagreed with the proposal of a cap on recovery fees took issue with the level of the cap, asserting that it did not reflect the actual enforcement cost. Eight per cent of those respondents contested the notion that an unpaid parking charge was unequivocally a debt, preferring to leave it to a court to decide. Impact on debt recovery agencies The government acknowledges that there will be some direct costs to debt recovery agencies who rely on additional fees for their revenue, or to parking operators who will have to pay for debt-recovery services from the revenue from parking charges. The response does not, however, consider whether parking operators will charge the maximum parking charge notice (PCN) amount permissible under the Code, rather than the current landscape, where charges are often set below the capped amount. The governments response goes on to state that there may be the indirect cost of a loss of deterrent effect, which may lead to less efficient parking management. Before the implementation of the new Code for PCNs, there will be an interim period in which additional fees have been charged legitimately. Should court action be necessary to pursue any of those, provided those claims are issued before the legal obligation to cease adding a debt-recovery fee comes into force, the recovery fees may be claimed. However, operators may find a higher degree of resistance by courts to granting the claim in light of the provisions of the Code even before it comes into force. britishparking.co.uk 21 PN Apr 2022 pp20-21 Legal.indd 21 24/03/2022 14:10